As a fan, I appreciated that XG gave us a closer look at what happened to Chisa during the Paris leg of the tour. Seeing her collapse, cared for by staff, and still choosing to return to stage—even briefly—was difficult but important to witness. It reminded us that these performers, no matter how polished they appear, are still human.
Some say this should’ve been kept under wraps. Others criticize the tour schedule itself. Both are valid concerns. But personally, I think what XG did here was the right move.
This wasn’t a hospital report. It wasn’t trauma porn. It was controlled transparency—enough to acknowledge something serious happened, enough to show she was cared for, and enough to quiet speculation without crossing into invasive territory. That kind of balance builds trust.
Idols don’t owe us every detail. But if something affects a performance or member visibly, silence can breed rumors worse than the truth. By choosing to share this—presumably with Chisa’s consent—XG respected both their fans and their member.
Hopefully, it also leads to internal reflection about the demands of touring. If fans are speaking up about grueling schedules, it’s not just criticism—it’s concern. And concern, like transparency, should never be ignored.